Payroll
Employee or Independent Contractor?
Worker classification determines who pays payroll taxes and which forms are filed. It depends on the facts of the working relationship, not on what the parties call it.
4 min read Updated
When a business pays someone for work, that person is either an employee or an independent contractor. The distinction decides who pays which taxes, what forms are filed, and what protections the worker has. It is also one of the areas where small businesses most often make costly mistakes.
Why it matters
For an employee, the business must withhold federal and state income tax, withhold Social Security and Medicare taxes and pay a matching share, pay federal and state unemployment taxes, generally carry workers' compensation coverage, and issue a Form W-2 after the year ends.
For an independent contractor, the business generally does none of that. It pays the agreed amount and, when payments for the year reach the reporting threshold, issues a Form 1099-NEC. The contractor is responsible for their own income tax and self-employment tax.
The difference in cost and paperwork is considerable, which is exactly why classification is scrutinized.
It is not a matter of preference
A business cannot make a worker a contractor by calling them one. A signed agreement that describes the worker as an independent contractor is relevant, but it does not settle the question. Neither does the fact that the worker asked to be paid that way, works part time, or is paid by the job.
What matters is the actual relationship, and specifically the degree of control the business has and the degree of independence the worker has.
What the IRS looks at
The IRS groups the relevant facts into three categories.
Behavioral control. Does the business control, or have the right to control, what the worker does and how they do it? Setting hours, requiring particular methods, providing training on how to do the job, and supervising the work all point toward employment. A contractor is generally told what result is wanted and decides how to achieve it.
Financial control. Who bears the business side of the work? A contractor typically has their own tools and equipment, pays their own expenses, can work for other clients, and can make or lose money on a job. An employee is usually paid a wage or salary, is reimbursed for expenses, and uses the employer's equipment.
The relationship of the parties. Is there a written contract? Does the worker receive benefits such as paid time off or insurance? Is the arrangement expected to continue indefinitely? Is the work a central part of the business's regular operations? Ongoing, open-ended work that is core to the business suggests employment.
No single factor decides it. The whole relationship is weighed.
Two examples
A bakery hires a counter worker. The owner sets the schedule, trains her on the register, provides a uniform, and pays her hourly. She works only for the bakery. She is an employee, whatever any paperwork says.
The same bakery hires an electrician to rewire its kitchen. He gives a quote, brings his own tools, decides how to do the job, has many other customers, and sends an invoice when he is finished. He is an independent contractor.
Most situations that cause trouble fall between these two: the long-term "freelancer" who works set hours at the business's location, or the delivery driver who uses their own vehicle but follows the company's routes and rules. These require a careful look at the facts.
State rules can differ
Minnesota agencies apply their own tests for unemployment insurance, workers' compensation and other purposes, and they do not always match the federal approach. Certain industries, including construction, have specific Minnesota requirements. A worker can be treated as a contractor for one purpose and an employee for another, so it is important to consider state rules as well as federal ones.
What happens when it is wrong
If a business treats an employee as a contractor and the classification is challenged, the business can be held liable for the employment taxes it should have withheld and paid, along with penalties and interest. State agencies may assess unpaid unemployment insurance and workers' compensation premiums. These assessments can cover several years and several workers at once.
A review is often triggered by something ordinary, such as a worker filing for unemployment benefits after the work ends.
If you are unsure
Either the business or the worker can ask the IRS for a determination by filing Form SS-8, though a response can take many months. In the meantime, it is wise to document why a worker was classified as they were, and to keep contracts, invoices and proof that a contractor operates an independent business.
For questions about the legal side of classification, including wage and hour rules, consult an employment attorney. For the payroll and tax reporting side, including W-2 and 1099 preparation, our payroll services can help. You may also find it useful to read What Does It Really Cost to Hire an Employee?
