AMS & Associates, Inc. For All Your Accounting Needs.

Business Taxes

Why Choosing the Right Business Structure Matters

Your business structure determines which tax returns you file, how you pay yourself, and how much administrative work you take on each year.

3 min read Updated

Most people choose a business structure in an afternoon, often on the advice of a friend or a website, and then live with the consequences for years. The decision deserves more attention than that. It affects four things every owner deals with: how the business is taxed, how the owner gets paid, what has to be filed, and what happens when the business changes.

Tax filing differences

Each structure reports its income differently.

A sole proprietor reports business income on Schedule C, which is part of the owner's personal Form 1040. There is no separate business income tax return.

A partnership, including most multi-member LLCs, files Form 1065. The partnership generally pays no income tax itself. It issues a Schedule K-1 to each partner, who reports their share on a personal return.

An S corporation files Form 1120-S and also issues Schedule K-1s to its owners.

A C corporation files Form 1120 and pays corporate income tax on its own profit. Shareholders are taxed separately on any dividends they receive.

Partnership and S corporation returns are generally due in mid-March, a month before individual returns, because the owners need their K-1s in order to file. Missing that earlier deadline is a common and avoidable source of penalties.

How owners are paid

In a sole proprietorship or partnership, owners do not receive a paycheck. They take draws from the business, and they pay income tax and self-employment tax on their share of the profit whether or not they took the money out.

In an S corporation or C corporation, an owner who works in the business is an employee. The business runs payroll, withholds taxes, and issues a W-2. This changes the owner's cash flow, the timing of tax payments, and the amount of paperwork involved.

Administrative requirements

The more formal the structure, the more it asks of you.

A sole proprietor needs good records and a set of estimated tax payments. A partnership adds a separate return and K-1s. Corporations add payroll for owners, payroll tax filings every quarter, and state filings to keep the entity in good standing. None of this is unmanageable, but it is real work with real deadlines, and it continues every year whether the business had a good year or a poor one.

Liability considerations

Sole proprietorships and general partnerships do not separate the owner from the business legally. LLCs and corporations are separate legal entities. How much protection that provides in a given situation is a legal question, and it should be discussed with a qualified attorney. It is worth knowing, however, that liability protection comes from the legal entity and not from any tax election.

Long-term implications

The structure that suits a business in its first year may be a poor fit later. A consultant working alone has different needs from the same consultant three years on, with employees, a lease and steady profit. Bringing in a partner, seeking outside investment, or planning to sell the business each raise their own considerations.

Changing structures is possible, but it is not always simple, and some changes carry tax costs. It helps to ask at the outset where the business is likely to be in a few years, and to revisit the question when circumstances change.

Questions to ask before deciding

  • How many owners are there, and will that change?
  • How much profit is the business expected to earn, and how steady will it be?
  • Will the owners work in the business full time?
  • Will the business have employees?
  • Is there a plan to bring in investors or sell?
  • How much administrative work are the owners prepared to take on or pay for?

There is no structure that is right for everyone, which is why general advice on this subject is so often wrong for the person receiving it. For a closer look at the comparison people ask about most, see LLC vs. S Corporation: What's the Difference? If you would like to go through the tax side of the decision for your own business, contact our office.

Contact our office

Tell us what you need help with. We will let you know how we can assist and what information to bring.