Individual Taxes
Why a Bigger Tax Refund Doesn't Always Mean You Paid Less Tax
A refund is the difference between what you paid during the year and what you owed. Its size says little about how much tax you actually paid.
3 min read Updated
For many people, the refund is the tax return. A big one means a good year; a small one, or a balance due, means something went wrong. It is an understandable way to keep score, and it measures the wrong thing.
What a refund is
Your return calculates your total tax for the year. It then adds up what you have already paid toward that tax, mainly through withholding from your paychecks and any estimated payments, along with refundable credits you qualify for.
If your payments and credits are more than your tax, the difference is refunded. If they are less, you owe the difference.
A refund is the return of an overpayment. It is your money, sent back to you without interest.
Same tax, different refunds
Two coworkers, Dana and Luis, earn the same salary and have identical tax situations. Each has a total federal tax of $6,000 for the year.
| Dana | Luis | |
|---|---|---|
| Total tax | $6,000 | $6,000 |
| Withheld during the year | $7,800 | $5,400 |
| Result at filing | $1,800 refund | $600 due |
Dana is pleased and Luis is annoyed. But both paid exactly $6,000 in tax. Dana had $150 more than necessary taken from her pay every month and got it back the following spring. Luis had $50 a month more in his paychecks all year and settled the difference when he filed.
Neither result is better in itself. They reflect different choices about withholding, often made years ago on a form neither of them remembers filling out.
The number that matters
To know how much tax you paid, look at the line on your return labeled total tax. That is the figure to compare from one year to the next, and against your income. Dividing it by your income gives your effective tax rate, which is far more informative than the size of the refund.
Why refunds change from year to year
Withholding changed. A new job, a raise, a second job, or a new Form W-4 will change how much is withheld. Two jobs are a frequent cause of under-withholding, because each employer withholds as though it were your only income.
Income changed. Side income, unemployment benefits, investment gains or retirement distributions may have little or no tax withheld.
Credits and deductions changed. A child who ages out of a credit, a change in filing status, or the end of an education credit can change the result by thousands of dollars.
The law changed. Tax rates, the standard deduction and credit amounts are adjusted by Congress and for inflation.
When a refund shrinks, the cause is usually one of these, and it can be identified by comparing the two returns line by line.
Credits are the exception
Some refunds really do represent more than your own withholding. Refundable credits, such as the Earned Income Tax Credit and the refundable portion of the Child Tax Credit, can produce a refund larger than the amount you paid in. In that case a larger refund does mean a better outcome. The point is to know which you are looking at: your own overpayment coming back, or a credit you qualified for.
Is a large refund a good thing?
That depends on the person. Some people treat over-withholding as forced savings and are happy to receive a lump sum each spring. Others would rather have the money in each paycheck to cover bills or pay down debt.
What is worth avoiding is the other extreme. Withholding too little can leave a balance you cannot pay easily, and may result in an underpayment penalty.
If your refund or balance due is far from what you would like, you can adjust it by giving your employer a new Form W-4. The IRS provides an online withholding estimator, and we are glad to help you review your withholding when we prepare your return.
A caution about promises
Be wary of anyone who promises a bigger refund before looking at your documents. A preparer's job is to report your income accurately and claim what you are entitled to. Two honest preparers working from the same information should arrive at essentially the same tax. A refund that is larger because of deductions or credits you do not qualify for is not a refund you get to keep, and you, not the preparer, are responsible for what is on your return.
For help with your return, see our tax preparation services.
